New Jersey Rises to Third in Hospital Safety Rankings; Newark Hospitals Receive A and B Grades
Saint Michael’s Medical Center earns an A and Newark Beth Israel Medical Center receives a B in Leapfrog’s Fall 2026 assessment. Meanwhile, questions remain about University Hospital’s current rating.
NEWARK, NJ — November 19, 2026 — The newly released Newark hospital safety grades for Fall 2026 show split results across the city’s major medical centers. Statewide, New Jersey climbed to third in the nation for overall hospital patient safety, according to Wednesday’s report from The Leapfrog Group.
The Fall 2026 Hospital Safety Grades awarded A ratings to 36 New Jersey hospitals, or 53.7% of graded facilities. That marks a 10.4 percentage-point jump from spring, when 43.3% earned an A and New Jersey ranked sixth nationally.
In Newark, Saint Michael’s Medical Center received an A, while Newark Beth Israel Medical Center earned a B. Both hospitals held steady from their spring grades.
University Hospital, Newark’s public academic medical center and Level I trauma center, received a C in Spring 2026. Accessible hospital-specific records did not confirm its Fall 2026 grade at the time of publication.
Breakdown of Newark Hospital Safety Grades for Fall 2026
| Hospital | Fall 2026 Grade | Spring 2026 Grade | Notable Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Saint Michael’s Medical Center 111 Central Ave., Downtown Newark |
A | A | Earned an A for at least five straight cycles, qualifying for Leapfrog’s Straight A recognition. |
| Newark Beth Israel Medical Center 201 Lyons Ave., South Ward |
B | B | Confirmed via a Nov. 18 RWJBarnabas Health announcement; all 12 system acute-care hospitals earned an A (7) or B (5). |
| University Hospital 150 Bergen St., Central Ward |
Unconfirmed | C | Fall 2026 rating remained unverified at publication; earned C grades in Spring 2026 and both 2025 cycles. |
Saint Michael’s Medical Center operates at 111 Central Avenue in Downtown Newark. It joins 35 other New Jersey hospitals in earning an A this fall. The hospital has now captured Leapfrog’s top rating for at least five straight cycles, earning Straight A recognition.
Newark Beth Israel Medical Center, located at 201 Lyons Avenue in the South Ward, received a B. Parent system RWJBarnabas Health confirmed the score in a November 18 announcement. Across the system, all 12 acute-care hospitals earned either an A or B, with seven scoring an A and five earning a B.
Nearby hospitals posted strong marks as well. Clara Maass Medical Center in Belleville climbed from a B in the spring to an A this fall, while Cooperman Barnabas Medical Center in Livingston received a B.
For University Hospital, accessible Leapfrog records still show a C from Spring 2026. The hospital also posted C grades in both 2025 cycles. Readers should not mistake those past scores for a confirmed Fall 2026 rating.
What Do Hospital Safety Grades Actually Measure?
Leapfrog’s Hospital Safety Grade measures how well hospitals protect patients from preventable errors, infections, injuries, and accidents. The scoring system tracks up to 22 evidence-based measures, including a federal composite score covering 10 preventable complications.
Specifically, Leapfrog examines hospital-acquired infections, surgical complications, and medication accuracy. Evaluators also review staff-to-patient communication and error-prevention protocols.
Letter grades run from A to F, with A signaling the strongest safety record. These scores give patients a standardized way to compare local hospitals.
Understanding the Limits of a Single Letter Grade
Still, a single letter grade does not capture every service a hospital offers. An A cannot guarantee zero complications, and a lower score does not mean every department provides poor care.
Hospitals also treat vastly different patient populations and case complexities. When planning scheduled procedures, residents should weigh safety grades alongside specialist credentials and personal medical needs.
New Jersey’s Rise in the National Rankings
New Jersey’s third-place ranking trails only Connecticut (64.3% A grades) and Utah (55.2%). Jumping from sixth place in the spring reflects a wider share of state hospitals earning top safety marks.
Nationwide, Leapfrog awarded 900 hospitals an A, 774 a B, 655 a C, 35 a D, and three an F.
Leapfrog President and CEO Leah Binder urged patients to weigh medical costs alongside patient safety outcomes. The group cited research from the Purchaser Business Group on Health showing almost no link between higher hospital prices and better safety scores.
In short, pricier care does not guarantee safer care. Patients benefit when they look beyond price tags, brand reputation, or convenience alone.
Why Some Hospitals Did Not Receive Grades
An important caveat shapes this fall’s national report. Leapfrog withheld grades from 447 hospitals that did not complete its 2025 or 2026 Hospital Survey.
This policy follows a South Florida federal court ruling involving five hospitals. Leapfrog applied the approach nationwide to keep its scoring uniform.
Those facilities carry a Grade Not Assigned label, which does not signal unsafe care or a failing score. However, excluding ungraded facilities means state rankings do not reflect every eligible hospital.
What the Fall 2026 Hospital Safety Grades Mean for Newark
Newark’s three hospitals fill distinct clinical roles across the region. Saint Michael’s delivers inpatient and outpatient care in Downtown Newark. Newark Beth Israel anchors the South Ward with specialized cardiac and pediatric programs, while University Hospital serves as the region’s public academic medical center and Level I trauma hub.
Because their missions differ, patients should look past the headline letter grade. Drilling down into infection rates, medication safety, and nurse communication reveals how each hospital performs day to day.
Meanwhile, University Hospital continues its campus modernization—a project The Newark Times follows within our broader Newark public health and hospital infrastructure coverage. Still, new buildings do not automatically equal safer clinical outcomes until future performance data proves it.
The Grades Reflect Earlier Reporting Periods
Although Leapfrog published these scores in November 2026, much of the underlying data comes from earlier years. Several federal safety indicators cover July 2022 through June 2024. As a result, the grades offer a retrospective snapshot rather than a live report card.
Leapfrog also adjusted its Fall 2026 formula after federal officials paused data on staff responsiveness. The group temporarily dropped that metric and gave extra weight to nurse communication until the measure returns in Spring 2027. Shifts between cycles can reflect clinical changes, updated data windows, or scoring tweaks.
How Patients Can Use the Information
Newark residents can use these safety grades as a practical starting point for planned care. Before scheduling a procedure, ask doctors about infection controls, medication checks, and complication protocols.
You can review full hospital profiles and historical scores online at HospitalSafetyGrade.org. Combine those records with your physician’s advice and your specific medical needs.
In a medical emergency, always seek immediate care rather than delaying treatment to compare hospital grades.
A Continuing Measure of Newark’s Healthcare
New Jersey’s jump to third place nationally marks welcome progress. For Newark families, however, local hospital performance matters most.
Saint Michael’s A rating and Newark Beth Israel’s B confirm solid safety marks this fall, while University Hospital’s current rating still awaits confirmation. Together, these benchmarks help residents track whether clinical upgrades translate into safer care.
Leapfrog releases its next round of grades in Spring 2027. Until then, these findings offer useful guidance while reminding patients to look closely at what safety scores measure—and what they leave unanswered.
Join the Conversation
- What information about hospital safety and patient care would help you most when choosing a hospital?
- How can Newark’s healthcare institutions make their safety data easier for residents to understand?
- Which experiences at Newark-area hospitals have shaped your view of patient safety?






